Loyalty Card Holder

Do you have a number of loyalty cards from various shops?  I used to have them all in my wallet, until it broke and I had to buy a new one (wallet, that is), which did not have the capacity for all the cards.

So, today I made a couple of little holders, one for my coffee cards and the other for shop loyalty cards.
 
Two designs were trialled, one with a split ring so that it can be hooked onto my keyring or inside my handbag and the other just a little holder.

Which do you prefer?

Lucky they are only for me, as you can see that the front is showing the fabric the wrong way up, it is perfect on the back, he he

Judy